Arguments for and against Molinism | Dr. Daniel Rubio

 

Agnostic Joe Schmid and (Catholic?) Daniel Rubio discuss arguments for and (ESPECIALLY) against Molinism. 

Arguments for and against Molinism | Dr. Daniel Rubio
https://youtu.be/y92T1xEBJHk

 

 

Tim Stratton (Molinist) and Chris Date (Calvinist) Discuss Theological Determinism

 

Tim Stratton (Molinist) and Chris Date (Calvinist) Discuss Theological Determinism
https://youtu.be/8-OAlGL7cVg

Stratton vs Date Discussion Review
With Tyler Vela and Colton Carlson
https://youtu.be/gkcDVa6yEhc

Review of Tim Stratton and Chris Date on Determinism
With Dan Chapa and Turretinfan
https://youtu.be/0pEPP1N5PKs

Dr. Kirk MacGregor Vs Dr. Guillaume Bignon: Calvinism Vs Molinism: The Problem or Evil EP 239

 

Dr. Kirk MacGregor Vs Dr. Guillaume Bignon: Calvinism Vs Molinism: The Problem or Evil EP 239
https://youtu.be/1wtPCXv-BDk

Thinking about Middle Knowledge: An Interview with Dr. Travis Campbell

 

Below are links to Dr. Travis Campbell's interview by Reasons To Believe on the topic of Middle Knowledge. Campbell received his PhD in philosophical theology from Westminster Theological Seminary in Philadelphia in 2004. I was highly impressed by his paper "Middle Knowledge: A Reformed Critique" when I first read it years ago. Today I found out that he was interviewed by RTB.

I've linked to the two part interview and the original paper below:

Part ONE of the Interview

Part TWO of the Interview

Original Paper: Middle Knowledge: A Reformed Critique or [HERE]

More Links to Calvinistic Responses to Molinism and Middle Knowledge: HERE 

300 Page Response to MERE MOLINISM with Colton Carlson

Colton Carlson interviewed regarding his 300 page response to and critique of Tim Stratton's book Human Freedom, Divine Knowledge, and Mere Molinism: A Biblical, Historical, Theological, and Philosophical Analysis.

300 Page Response to MERE MOLINISM
https://youtu.be/WAsHqEU82lg

See also the series of videos where Colton Carlson reviews the book Mere Molinism. Here's a link to PART ONE of the video series:    https://youtu.be/yZ_-eJ9EFa0

UPDATE: ALL THREE VOLUMES LINKED BELOW 

 A Brief Philosophical & Dialectical Inquiry on Mere Molinism: A Compatibilist Reply | VOLUME 1 by Colton Carlson
Freely Downloadable HERE or HERE

VOLUME 2 Freely Downloadable HERE or HERE

VOLUME 3 Freely Downloadable HERE

Guillaume Bignon Comments on the Highly Anticipated Dialogue/Debate Between William Lane Craig and James White

 

The following video is (Calvinist) Guillaume Bignon's commentary on the recent dialogue/debate between (Molinist) William Lane Craig and (Calvinist) James White. What I really like about Bignon is that he's not only well versed in the debate between Calvinists and non-Calvinists, but he can express and defend the Calvinistic view very well and articulately. 

William Lane Craig vs. James R. White: Calvinist Philosopher Weighs In
https://youtu.be/EGUi5ZZkAzs

In the video (at 56:45) Guillaume makes reference to his nearly two hour interview on the topic of the Manipulation argument on the Parker's Pensées podcast episode 27 HERE.

---

---

---

Here's the original video Bignon is commenting on.

 William Lane Craig vs James White - Calvinism vs Molinism on the Problem of Evil
https://youtu.be/ECcN-fisQRk

---

---

---

Here's James White's Post-Debate Interview by Eli Ayala

James R. White vs. William Lane Craig (Post-Debate Interview)
https://youtu.be/G74B8vdsgIw

A Top Calvinist Answers Objections By Top Anti-Calvinists

Calvinist Guillaume Bignon interviewed and responds to the objections given by his anti-Calvinist friends Leighton Flowers, Tim Stratton, & Braxton Hunter.


French Calvinist Philosopher Responds to Critics [3/28/2020]
https://youtu.be/rP2BWwC9M3s

(Part 2): Guillaume Responds to Leighton Flowers, Tim Stratton, & Braxton Hunter. [5/2/2020]
https://youtu.be/mX6IvrmFUos

A critical review and fairly comprehensive refutation of“Human Freedom, Divine Knowledge, and Mere Molinism”by Timothy A. Stratton by Guillaume Bignon [or HERE]

A response to Kevin Timpe’s objections [in his book review] by Guillaume Bignon [or HERE]

---

The three critics joined together to respond to the first video on their respective channels. Part 2 of Bignon's interview occurred after the following videos were post. So, if you want to watch the videos chronologically, watch Part 2 after watching the following three videos below.

Determinism refuted Biblically [4/3/2020]
https://youtu.be/oSMJRTghRtM

Determinism Refuted Theologically [4/10/2020]
https://youtu.be/w7qcmZ-cO_M

Determinism Refuted Philosophically [4/17/2020]
https://youtu.be/sjIMbNnaG94

Calvinistic Responses to Molinism

(originally posted 11/1/2015)

There are many Calvinistic Responses to Molinism both on the internet and in book form. The following are just a sample.



James Anderson's blogposts dealing with Molinism
(This is a link to Anderson's blogposts with the Tag/Label "Molinism")

How Biblical is Molinism? (Part 1) by James Anderson
How Biblical is Molinism? (Part 2) by James Anderson
How Biblical is Molinism? (Part 3) by James Anderson
How Biblical is Molinism? (Part 4) by James Anderson
How Biblical is Molinism? (Part 5) by James Anderson
How Biblical is Molinism? (Part 6) by James Anderson

Yes, Molina, There Could Have Been a Santa Claus by James Anderson

 A Brief Philosophical & Dialectical Inquiry on Mere Molinism: A Compatibilist Reply | VOLUME 1 by Colton Carlson
Freely Downloadable HERE or HERE

VOLUME 2 Freely Downloadable HERE or HERE

VOLUME 3 Freely Downloadable HERE

Colton Carlson VIDEO where he is interviewed regarding his 300 PAGE response to Stratton's book Mere Molinism: HERE

Colton Carlson VIDEO SERIES where he reviews Stratton's book Mere Molinism. Here's the link to PART ONE of the Series: HERE


Middle Knowledge: A Reformed Critique by Travis James Campbell [or HERE]


Greg Welty's Blogposts dealing with Molinism
(This is a link to Welty's blogposts with the Tag/Label "Molinism")


A critical review and fairly comprehensive refutation of“Human Freedom, Divine Knowledge, and Mere Molinism”by Timothy A. Stratton by Guillaume Bignon [or HERE]


Does Molinism Avoid Making God the Author of Sin? | Welty on Molinism by James A. Gibson
[archived HERE]

Tyler Vela's Criticisms of Molinism
http://freedthinkerpodcast.blogspot.com/2018/07/molinism-collection.html

Turretin on Molinism by "Turretinfan"
https://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=6033E4C50E7BEDE8

Triablogue blogposts with the Label/Tag of "Molinism"
(There are more Triablogue blogposts which deal with Molinism but unfortunately they don't have the "Molinism" label)


See also my blogpost: Free Will, Moral Responsibility, and Reformed Theology by Paul Manata